2025 ballot for Matt Prigge
Best Picture
- It Was Just an Accident 20
- If I Had Legs I'd Kick You 15
- Afternoons of Solitude 10
- Eephus 10
- The Mastermind 10
- One Battle After Another 10
- The Shrouds 10
- Caught by the Tides 5
- Grand Tour 5
- Henry Fonda for President 5
Best Director
- Mary Bronstein, If I Had Legs I'd Kick You 20
- Jafar Panahi, It Was Just an Accident 15
- Paul Thomas Anderson, One Battle After Another 15
- Carson Lund, Eephus 10
- Kelly Reichardt, The Mastermind 10
- David Cronenberg, The Shrouds 10
- Albert Serra, Afternoons of Solitude 5
- Jia Zhang-ke, Caught by the Tides 5
- Radu Jude, Dracula 5
- Miguel Gomes, Grand Tour 5
Best Actress
- Rose Byrne, If I Had Legs I'd Kick You 20
- Kathleen Chalfant, Familiar Touch 15
- Chase Infiniti, One Battle After Another 15
- Jennifer Lawrence, Die My Love 10
- Renate Reinsve, Sentimental Value 10
- Amanda Seyfried, The Testament of Ann Lee 10
- Susan Chardy, On Becoming a Guinea Fowl 5
- Emma Mackey, Ella McCay 5
- Emma Stone, Bugonia 5
- Zhao Tao, Caught by the Tides 5
Best Actor
- Leonardo DiCaprio, One Battle After Another 20
- Ethan Hawke, Blue Moon 15
- Kyle Marvin, Splitsville 10
- Vahid Mobasseri, It Was Just an Accident 10
- Wagner Moura, The Secret Agent 10
- Josh O'Connor, Wake Up Dead Man 10
- Denzel Washington, Highest 2 Lowest 10
- Michael B. Jordan, Sinners 5
- Vincent Cassel, The Shrouds 5
- Tim Robinson, Friendship 5
Best Supporting Actor
- Andrew Scott, Blue Moon 20
- Benicio del Toro, One Battle After Another 15
- Stellan Skarsgård, Sentimental Value 15
- Ebrahim Azizi, It Was Just an Accident 10
- Sean Penn, One Battle After Another 10
- A$AP Rocky, If I Had Legs I'd Kick You 10
- Jacques Develay, Misericordia 5
- Spike Fearn, Ella McCay 5
- Kevin O'Leary, Marty Supreme 5
- Guy Pearce, The Shrouds 5
Best Supporting Actress
- Teyana Taylor, One Battle After Another 20
- Regina Hall, One Battle After Another 15
- Zoë Kravitz, Caught Stealing 15
- Mariam Afshari, It Was Just an Accident 10
- Odessa A'zion, Marty Supreme 10
- Sissy Spacek, Die My Love 10
- Elle Fanning, Sentimental Value 5
- Gaby Hoffmann, The Mastermind 5
- Julie Kavner, Ella McCay 5
- Gwyneth Paltrow, Marty Supreme 5
Best Screenplay
- Jafar Panahi, It Was Just an Accident 20
- Mary Bronstein, If I Had Legs I'd Kick You 15
- Paul Thomas Anderson, One Battle After Another 15
- Michael Basta & Nate Fisher & Carson Lund, Eephus 10
- Kelly Reichardt, The Mastermind 10
- Michael Angelo Covino & Kyle Marvin, Splitsville 10
- Robert Kaplow, Blue Moon 5
- Miguel Gomes et al., Grand Tour 5
- Ronald Bronstein & Josh Safdie, Marty Supreme 5
- David Cronenberg, The Shrouds 5
Best Scene
- We're on the road to nowhere, One Battle After Another 20
- Enemy mines, Sirāt 15
- Subway drop, Highest 2 Lowest 15
- Final confrontation, It Was Just an Accident 10
- Snowman, The Naked Gun 10
- Toad tripping at Subway, Friendship 10
- Dressing Andrés, Afternoons of Solitude 5
- Hamster, If I Had Legs I'd Kick You 5
- MRI, Final Destination Bloodlines 5
- "Where Have All the Flowers Gone?", Bugonia 5
Top Ten List
- 1. It Was Just an Accident
- 2. If I Had Legs I'd Kick You
- 3. The Shrouds
- 4. The Mastermind
- 5. One Battle After Another
- 6. Eephus
- 7. Afternoons of Solitude
- 8. Caught by the Tides
- 9. Grand Tour
- 10. Henry Fonda for President
Ratings
- 28 Years Later 2.5
- Afternoons of Solitude 3.5
- After the Hunt 1.5
- Avatar: Fire and Ash 2.5
- Black Bag 3.0
- Blue Moon 3.0
- Bugonia 2.5
- Caught by the Tides 3.5
- Caught Stealing 2.5
- Cloud 3.0
- The Day the Earth Blew Up 2.5
- Die My Love 2.5
- Dracula 3.0
- Eddington 3.0
- Eephus 3.5
- Ella McCay 3.0
- F1 3.0
- Father Mother Sister Brother 3.0
- Final Destination Bloodlines 3.0
- Flight Risk 2.0
- Frankenstein 2.5
- Friendship 2.5
- Grand Tour 3.5
- Happy Gilmore 2 2.5
- Hedda 2.5
- Henry Fonda for President 3.5
- Highest 2 Lowest 3.0
- Honey Don't! 2.5
- The Housemaid 2.5
- If I Had Legs I'd Kick You 3.5
- It Was Just an Accident 3.5
- Jay Kelly 2.0
- Marty Supreme 3.0
- The Mastermind 3.5
- Materialists 2.5
- Megadoc 3.0
- Mickey 17 3.0
- Misericordia 3.0
- Mission: Impossible—The Final Reckoning 2.5
- The Naked Gun 3.0
- No Other Choice 3.0
- Nouvelle Vague 3.0
- On Becoming a Guinea Fowl 2.5
- One Battle After Another 3.5
- Pavements 3.0
- Peter Hujar's Day 3.0
- The Phoenician Scheme 3.0
- Predator: Badlands 3.0
- Predators 3.0
- Resurrection 2.5
- The Running Man 2.5
- The Secret Agent 3.0
- Sentimental Value 3.0
- Seven Veils 3.0
- The Shrouds 3.5
- Sinners 3.0
- Sirāt 3.0
- Sly Lives! (aka The Burden of Genius) 3.0
- Sorry, Baby 2.5
- Splitsville 3.0
- Superman 2.5
- The Testament of Ann Lee 3.0
- Together 2.0
- Train Dreams 2.5
- Wake Up Dead Man 3.0
- Weapons 3.0
- Where to Land 3.0
- Wolf Man 2.0