2016 ballot for Scott Tobias
Best Picture
- The Handmaiden 15
- Manchester By The Sea 15
- Silence 15
- Toni Erdmann 15
- Paterson 10
- Right Now, Wrong Then 10
- Aquarius 5
- Elle 5
- Jackie 5
- Moonlight 5
Best Director
- Park Chan-wook, The Handmaiden 20
- Martin Scorsese, Silence 15
- Fede Alvarez, Don't Breathe 10
- Joel Coen & Ethan Coen, Hail, Caesar! 10
- Barry Jenkins, Moonlight 10
- Nicolas Winding Refn, The Neon Demon 10
- Keith Maitland, Tower 10
- Paul Verhoeven, Elle 5
- Damien Chazelle, La La Land 5
- Robert Eggers, The Witch: A New-England Folktale 5
Best Actress
- Rebecca Hall, Christine 30
- Isabelle Huppert, Elle 30
- Kate Beckinsale, Love & Friendship 5
- Sonia Braga, Aquarius 5
- Krisha Fairchild, Krisha 5
- Sandra Hüller, Toni Erdmann 5
- Isabelle Huppert, Things to Come 5
- Kate Lyn Sheil, Kate Plays Christine 5
- Ruth Negga, Loving 5
- Natalie Portman, Jackie 5
Best Actor
- Casey Affleck, Manchester By The Sea 30
- Adam Driver, Paterson 15
- John Goodman, 10 Cloverfield Lane 10
- Trevante Rhodes, Moonlight 10
- Peter Simonischek, Toni Erdmann 10
- Joel Edgerton, Loving 5
- Colin Farrell, The Lobster 5
- Andrew Garfield, Silence 5
- Ryan Gosling, The Nice Guys 5
- Tom Hanks, Sully 5
Best Supporting Actor
- Issey Ogata, Silence 20
- Michael Shannon, Nocturnal Animals 20
- Tom Bennett, Love & Friendship 15
- Alden Ehrenreich, Hail, Caesar! 15
- Mahershala Ali, Moonlight 5
- Tadanobu Asano, Silence 5
- Lucas Hedges, Manchester By The Sea 5
- André Holland, Moonlight 5
- Tracy Letts, Indignation 5
- Glen Powell, Everybody Wants Some!! 5
Best Supporting Actress
- Lily Gladstone, Certain Women 30
- Hayley Squires, I, Daniel Blake 20
- Kate McKinnon, Ghostbusters 10
- Michelle Williams, Manchester By The Sea 10
- Laura Dern, Certain Women 5
- Paulina García, Little Men 5
- Riley Keough, American Honey 5
- Abbey Lee, The Neon Demon 5
- Jena Malone, The Neon Demon 5
- Kim Min-hee, The Handmaiden 5
Best Screenplay
- Kenneth Lonergan, Manchester By The Sea 15
- Shane Black & Anthony Bagarozzi, The Nice Guys 15
- Maren Ade, Toni Erdmann 15
- Joel Coen & Ethan Coen, Hail, Caesar! 10
- Park Chan-wook & Jeong Seo-kyeong, The Handmaiden 10
- Whit Stillman, Love & Friendship 10
- Hong Sang-soo, Right Now, Wrong Then 10
- Yorgos Lanthimos and Efthymis Filippou, The Lobster 5
- Jim Jarmusch, Paterson 5
- Robert Eggers, The Witch: A New-England Folktale 5
Best Scene
- An invitation to lunch, Manchester By The Sea 20
- "Would that it were so simple.", Hail, Caesar! 20
- A meeting with Dean Caudwell, Indignation 15
- Birthday party, Toni Erdmann 10
- "The Greatest Love of All", Toni Erdmann 10
- "Finest Girl (The Bin Laden Song)", Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping 5
- "No Dames", Hail, Caesar! 5
- Sand Job, Moonlight 5
- Scoping out Arlington , Jackie 5
- The Twelve Commandments, Love & Friendship 5
Top Ten List
- 1. Manchester By The Sea
- 2. Toni Erdmann
- 3. Silence
- 4. The Handmaiden
- 5. Paterson
- 6. Right Now, Wrong Then
- 7. Moonlight
- 8. Jackie
- 9. Elle
- 10. Aquarius
Ratings
- 10 Cloverfield Lane 3.0
- 13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi 1.0
- 13th 3.0
- 20th Century Women 2.5
- Absolutely Fabulous: The Movie 2.5
- The Age of Shadows 3.0
- All Roads Lead to Rome 1.0
- Almost Christmas 2.0
- Always Shine 2.5
- Amanda Knox 2.5
- American Honey 2.5
- The Angry Birds Movie 2.0
- The Apostate 3.0
- Aquarius 3.5
- Arrival 3.5
- Author: The JT LeRoy Story 3.0
- Bad Santa 2 1.0
- Barry 2.5
- Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice 2.0
- The BFG 3.5
- The Birth of a Nation 2.5
- Blair Witch 1.5
- The Boy 2.0
- Café Society 2.5
- Cameraperson 3.0
- Captain America: Civil War 2.5
- Captain Fantastic 2.5
- Cemetery of Splendour 3.0
- Certain Women 3.5
- Christine 3.5
- Collateral Beauty 0.0
- The Conjuring 2 2.5
- The Darkness 2.0
- Deadpool 2.5
- Deepwater Horizon 2.5
- Demolition 2.0
- De Palma 2.5
- Dheepan 2.5
- The Divergent Series: Allegiant 1.0
- Doctor Strange 2.5
- Don't Breathe 3.5
- Don't Think Twice 2.5
- Eddie the Eagle 2.0
- The Edge of Seventeen 3.0
- Elle 3.5
- Embrace of the Serpent 3.0
- Equals 2.0
- Everybody Wants Some!! 3.5
- Eye in the Sky 2.0
- Fifty Shades of Black 0.0
- Finding Dory 2.5
- Fire at Sea 3.0
- The Fits 3.0
- Five Nights in Maine 2.0
- Florence Foster Jenkins 2.5
- Ghostbusters 1.5
- Gimme Danger 3.0
- The Girl on the Train 2.0
- Gleason 3.0
- Gods of Egypt 2.0
- Green Room 3.0
- Hail, Caesar! 3.5
- The Handmaiden 4.0
- Hands of Stone 2.5
- Hell or High Water 3.0
- Hidden Figures 2.5
- High-Rise 2.5
- Hunt for the Wilderpeople 2.5
- I Am Not Your Negro 3.0
- I, Daniel Blake 2.5
- Indignation 3.0
- The Infiltrator 2.5
- Into the Forest 2.5
- The Invitation 3.0
- Jackie 3.5
- The Jungle Book 3.0
- Kate Plays Christine 3.0
- Keanu 3.0
- Knight of Cups 2.5
- Krisha 3.0
- Kubo and the Two Strings 3.0
- Lace Crater 2.5
- La La Land 3.0
- The Light Between Oceans 2.5
- Lights Out 2.5
- Little Men 3.0
- The Lobster 3.0
- London Has Fallen 1.0
- Louder Than Bombs 3.0
- Love & Friendship 3.5
- The Love Witch 1.5
- Loving 3.0
- The Magnificent Seven 2.0
- A Man Called Ove 2.5
- Manchester By The Sea 4.0
- Mascots 0.0
- Midnight Special 2.5
- Moana 3.5
- Mojave 1.5
- A Monster Calls 2.5
- Moonlight 3.5
- Mountains May Depart 2.5
- My Big Fat Greek Wedding 2 2.0
- Neighbors 2: Sorority Rising 2.0
- The Neon Demon 3.0
- Nerve 3.0
- The Nice Guys 3.5
- Nocturnal Animals 3.0
- Office Christmas Party 2.5
- O.J.: Made in America 3.5
- The Ones Below 2.5
- Our Little Sister 3.0
- Paterson 3.5
- Peter and the Farm 3.5
- Pete's Dragon 3.0
- Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping 3.0
- Presenting Princess Shaw 2.5
- Pride and Prejudice and Zombies 2.0
- The Prison in Twelve Landscapes 3.0
- The Program 2.0
- The Purge: Election Year 2.0
- Queen of Katwe 2.5
- Race 2.5
- Rams 3.0
- Right Now, Wrong Then 3.5
- Rogue One 3.0
- Search Party 1.0
- The Secret Life of Pets 2.0
- The Shallows 3.0
- Silence 4.0
- Sing 2.0
- Sing Street 2.5
- Snowden 2.0
- Snowtime! 2.0
- Southside With You 2.5
- Sully 3.0
- Swiss Army Man 2.5
- Things to Come 3.0
- Tickled 3.0
- Toni Erdmann 4.0
- Tower 3.5
- Trolls 2.5
- The Wailing 3.0
- A War 3.0
- Weiner 3.0
- Whiskey Tango Foxtrot 2.5
- Wiener-Dog 2.5
- The Witch: A New-England Folktale 3.5
- Zero Days 3.0
- Zoolander 2 1.0
- Zootopia 2.5