Best Supporting actress votes for Marisa Tomei in The Wrestler
- Josh Rothkopf 20
- Dave Cowen 15 *
- Charles Odell 14
- Jeremy Heilman 10
- Victor Morton 10
- Zach Ralston 10
- Missy Schwartz 10
- Froilan Vispo 10
- Andrew Wright 10
- Matthew Butcher 8
- Mark Pittillo 7
- Scott Renshaw 7
- Bilge Ebiri 5
- Rachel Jacobson 5
- Noel Murray 5
- Matt Prigge 5
- Peter Reiher 5 *
- Jim Ridley 5
- Michael Sicinski 5
- Scott Tobias 5
* Vote was in Actress category.