Best Supporting actor votes for Willem Dafoe in The Lighthouse
- Bryant Frazer 20
- Noel Murray 15
- Zach Ralston 15 *
- Don Marks 13
- Scott Renshaw 11
- Daniel Waters 11
- Matthew Butcher 10 *
- Luis Calil 10
- Jason Overbeck 10
- Chris Stults 10 *
- Jeremy Heilman 6
- Mark Pittillo 5 *
- Josh Rothkopf 5 *
- Scott Tobias 5 *
* Vote was in Actor category.