Best Actor votes for Casey Affleck in The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford
- Donna Bowman 25 *
- Bilge Ebiri 20
- Sky Hirschkron 20
- Matt Prigge 20
- Theo Panayides 17
- Noel Murray 15 *
- Rachel Jacobson 14
- Kathleen Tax 12
- Zach Ralston 11
- Steve Erickson 10 *
- Victor Morton 10 *
- Mark Pittillo 10
- Scott Renshaw 10
- Adam Villani 9
- Mike D'Angelo 8
- Scott Tobias 8 *
- Bryant Frazer 7
- Don Marks 7
- Charles Odell 5
* Vote was in Supporting Actor category.